Even though I looooveeeeeee cooking, there are times I have no idea what to make. Or more accurately, I don’t feel like making anything! I beg and plead with my husband to make me something because I know if he HAD to he could make a decent meal. He knows all my cooking secrets and what ingredients pair well together but he just pretends he has no clue. So on this night, when I had no idea what to make, I asked him my daily question, “What do you want for dinner?” Usually, he says, “anything” but on this day, glory be to God who helped me out, he said a roast of beef. Of course, I don’t have a beef roast on hand so obviously we have to go out and get one (after a stop to the video rental store of course to get some movie like Reservoir Dogs or something I am totally not interested in).
Once we reached the butcher, being a small city he didn’t have the beef tenderloin roast I was imagining in my head. But, an option of eye of round or prime rib. Though prime rib is YUM, I would like to save it for special occasions due to its fat content. I got the eye of round. I came home having no idea of what sort of cut it was, though the butcher said it was very tender and to cook it at a high temperature then turn it down for the remainder of the cooking time. I looked it up and it said it was a popular cut in the 1950’s. I thought to myself, “great, it’s like the food on the show Mad Men, an era when eating Ceasar Salad was exotic.” Anyhow, I ignored that and cook it as though it were a tenderloin. Giving the roast a bit of an ego boost if you will. I used my guru/mentor/idol’s (Ina Garten) style for making a filet roast. A link to her Filet of Beef recipe is here.
The preparation is so simple, that I know my husband could have done it just as well as me. No chopping (other than the potatoes), no slaving over the stove (just throw everything in the oven and forget about it)! The meat was tender and juicy. The perfect solution for a day where you don’t feel like cooking. Unless, you go out to eat or get takeout…..YUM!
*The 2 pound roast was reasonablly priced as well. My original tenderloin idea would have put a dent in our wallets. Hehe 🙂
Roast Eye of Round with Roasted Potatoes with a Pan Gravy
loosely inspired by Ina Garten
Eye of Round Roast
2 pound eye of round roast (ours was tied by the butcher with butcher’s twine)
1 whole bulb on garlic, peeled
1 1/2 teaspoons of kosher salt, or to taste
1 1/2 teaspoons of ground black pepper, or to taste
5-6 sprigs of thyme
3-4 Yukon gold potatoes in wedges
drizzle of olive oil
Preheat your oven to 500 degrees. Take a baking dish or sheet pan place the beef in the center cover with salt and pepper, leaving a little to put over the potatoes as well. Throw in the peeled garlic cloves. I poked holes in the meat and stuffed the holes with some whole cloves, but this is entirely optional. Put the potatoes in the dish, season them with some salt, pepper, and some thyme. Cover the beef with the thyme. Drizzle the whole dish with olive oil. Place in roast in the oven for 20 minutes at 500 degreees. After 20 minutes turn it down to 300 for about 30 minutes. After 30 minutes turn the oven off and let the roast sit for 10-15 more minutes. Take the roast out of the oven after 10-15 minutes and let it rest for about 15 minutes. Slice and serve. (This cooking time is for medium rare bordering medium).
*This roast tasted great the next day in sandwiches.
To make the gravy, take out any drippings from the beef baking dish. Put them in a small saucepan add about a tablespoon of flour. Whisk in the flour until it dissolves. I also added the leftover thyme sprigs into he gravy. Add 3/4 cup of chicken of beef stock and allow the gravy to thicken on medium heat for about 5-7 minutes. If you wish, you may add a dab of butter at the end to make the sauce glisten. Serve over the beef.
I also served a tomato, red onion, avocado salad on the side.